Frank Castle Vs. Jason Todd

[Dick Grayson]

Who's The More Dangerous, Vigilante??!!


ive had this idea, in the back of my mind for a few years now... i have said
before, that both Jason Todd and Frank Castle, are creations of Gerry
Conway...so they are pretty much comic book brothers if you will... they are
similar in their "lethal force" mentality for problem solvin...
i would answer first, but im a little biased...because Jason Todd is my
favorite comic book villain...

so here are the questions guys, in your opinion, who do you think is tougher,
smarter, meaner, and most violent, between Jason Todd and Frank Castle? also
who do you think would win, if both Jason Todd and Frank Castle were to battle
each other to the death, in both usin weapons, and just hand???

alright, PLACE YOUR BETS!!!!

[The Flash III]

Sorry, man, but there was once a What-if where the Punisher killed every hero and villain in the Marvel Universe. JT is toast...as it should be.

[Dick Grayson]

Sorry, man, but there was once a What-if where the Punisher killed every hero and villain in the Marvel Universe. JT is toast...as it should be.

since no one else is joinin in this thread, i guess it will just be you and me Flash. heres my view on this battle... while Frank is vicious, dangerous, vietnam vet, and intelligent... he doesnt have the Batman's trainin and dangerous mind. in the "What If" story, he might have killed everyone, but remember that those guys are Marvel... theres no Batman family characters in Marvel haha. in my opinion i think that Jason would kill Frank, because Jason is basically "the Punisher", but with the Batman's trainin... im sure that Bats, has faced up against characters similar to Castle, and they always end up goin down. Jason posses as much unique weapons, as Bruce does... Jason is also one of the only characters near Bats's intelligence when it comes to martial arts and acrobatics... hes probably right behind Grayson, in this department.

i see Jason, as a character that the Batman would have become, had Bats been a sadistic vigilante and murderer. Castle can be very sadistic yea, but lets remember that Jason is also a sick fck, because of all his mass murders...and Jason does it all while usin Bats trainin, plus the trainin from Bat's teachers. Jason knows most if not all of Bruce's tricks, so thats why i think that hes more dangerous than the Punisher. i would love to keep debatin this topic, because i think that it makes a good conversation.

[RiddleMeThis]

This one's easy, Jason Todd gets a bullet to the head. The fact that Jason's a mass murderer will only motivate Frank even more (but wait isn't the Punisher one as well? haha the irony in his logic).

[Dick Grayson]

This one's easy, Jason Todd gets a bullet to the head. The fact that Jason's a mass murderer will only motivate Frank even more (but wait isn't the Punisher one as well? haha the irony in his logic).

think about it man Jason has the Bat's mentality, the only thing is that Jason kills with what hes learned and Jason's always been a thug from day one.... also Jason is way younger than Frank... Jason is in his 20's and Frank is in his late 50... to say that Frank would hunt down and kill Jason, is to say that Frank can take Bruce Wayne.... while it is fact that Jason is no Bruce Wayne, Jason does infact possess all of Bruce's knowledge of crime fightin and tricks...but hes a lethal enforcer with the Bat's mentality...which makes him more dangerous in my opinion.

Bruce said it best in UTRH animation, "i knew from the beginin that he was dangerous... hes taken everythin that ive ever taught him, and turned it on me... its a hell of my own makin Alfred.." heavy words from the Bat...

[The Flash III]

Punisher would just dress up like the Joker and brandish a crowbar. Then, while JT is crappin his pants, bullet to the head. No way the Punisher loses.

[Dick Grayson]

Punisher would just dress up like the Joker and brandish a crowbar. Then, while JT is crappin his pants, bullet to the head. No way the Punisher loses.

haha that would happen, only if we were still in the 80's and Jason was still Robin... but hes learned alot since then, aside from what hes learned from Bruce, hes also been trained by Bruce's teachers... and carries a mess of spontaneous weapons... remember that in the Bat's world, the Bat family have the "expect, the unespected" mindset.. so i dont see Frank doin it like this... if theres ever a "snowball's chance in hell", that Frank does hunt down Jason... Jason will end up takin Frank with him... so they would both end up goin...

[bat1987]

If it was only H2H Jason would win this, as it is I give it to Frank because he packs a lot more firepower, and he`s one persistant SOB.